I thought we had somehow avoided sleep training.
Our son could hold his own bottle, soothe himself back to sleep, and everyone in the house was finally getting some rest. After months of recovering from labor, surviving on little sleep, and trying to figure out this whole parenting thing, it honestly felt like we had made it through one of the hardest stages.
Then daycare asked us a simple question.
"Has he started weaning from the bottle yet?"
My heart sank.
I had completely missed that milestone.
Like so many first-time parents, I had spent months googling every little thing.
Did that weird sound mean he was having trouble breathing?
Is it okay if he sleeps in his own room?
Should he be rolling over by now?
Are we creating a healthy attachment?
Eventually, I became exhausted by all of the conflicting advice. Every website seemed to say something different, every parent had a different opinion, and every expert promised they had the "right" answer.
At some point I finally looked at my husband and said, "We're doing our best. We have to trust that."
Ironically, while I had been worrying about a hundred tiny parenting decisions, I completely overlooked one important milestone: gradually weaning our son from the bottle.
I had always assumed that as we introduced solid foods, he would naturally drink less milk over time. I didn't realize that helping him fall asleep without a bottle would eventually become part of that process.
And that's when I realized something.
We hadn't avoided sleep training.
We had simply postponed it.
If you're anything like I was, you're probably exhausted, overwhelmed by all the conflicting advice online, and terrified of making the wrong decision for your child. I can't promise that sleep training is easy, but I can share the five biggest mistakes our family made along the way—and hopefully save you some of the stress, guilt, and second-guessing that came with learning these lessons ourselves.
Around the time my husband and I first started talking about sleep training, it honestly felt like a choice.
On Instagram, I saw moms saying they would never let their child "cry it out." They talked about how damaging it could be and how it might hurt the attachment they had worked so hard to build with their baby.
Then I had other friends sending me articles about the benefits of sleep training. Apparently, well-rested babies become confident, independent children. Some even claimed that sleep training helps children become more successful later in life.
The more I researched, the more anxious I became.
I desperately wanted to do what was best for my son, but every article seemed to tell me something different.
In the end, my husband and I decided not to sleep train.
Or at least... that's what we thought.
Our son had learned to hold his own bottle, and he could soothe himself back to sleep during the night. Instead of rocking him for hours, all we had to do was quickly make him a bottle, and everyone was back asleep within minutes.
Honestly, it felt like we had found a parenting hack.
Looking back, though, we hadn't actually solved the problem.
We had simply replaced one sleep association with another.
Our son wasn't falling asleep on his own—he was falling asleep with a bottle.
When daycare eventually pointed out that he would need to be weaned from the bottle, I realized there wasn't going to be an easy way around it.
Whether your baby falls asleep nursing, with a bottle, or being rocked to sleep, there usually comes a time when that sleep association needs to change.
And that change is hard.
It involves tears.
Whether you do it at six months, nine months, or a year old, there will probably be moments when your child protests because they're learning something new.
The first time we tried sleep training, I cried almost as much as my son did. Every time I heard him crying, I questioned whether I was doing the right thing.
When we tried again a few months later, something had changed.
My son wasn't the tiny newborn I had brought home from the hospital anymore. He was crawling, pulling himself up on furniture, and getting ready to walk. My postpartum hormones had settled, and while hearing him cry was still incredibly difficult, I wasn't consumed by the same fear that I was permanently damaging him.
I could finally remind myself that he was safe.
He was loved.
And he was learning a new skill.
Looking back, I honestly wish I had realized sooner that we couldn't avoid this forever.
Maybe waiting until he was older made it a little easier emotionally.
But it also meant that my husband and I spent months waking up multiple times every night when we probably didn't have to.
If I could go back, I wouldn't tell myself to sleep train earlier or later.
I'd simply remind myself that eventually our son would need to learn to fall asleep without a bottle—and that teaching him that skill wasn't something I needed to feel guilty about.
Every time he now falls asleep on his own, I feel incredibly proud of him.
He's growing up.
As bittersweet as that is, it's exactly what we're raising him to do.
If there was one thing that made sleep training harder than it needed to be, it was my obsession with doing it perfectly.
Before we even started, I read article after article about baby sleep. Every expert seemed to have a different opinion. Every parent I talked to had their own success story. Social media was full of people selling sleep courses or promising the "one method" that would finally get your baby sleeping through the night.
Instead of feeling prepared, I just felt overwhelmed.
What if we chose the wrong method?
What if we gave in too early?
What if we let him cry for too long?
What if we damaged our relationship with him?
The pressure was exhausting.
Then real life happened.
Our son started teething.
He caught a cold.
Family came to visit.
Grandma offered to babysit so my husband and I could finally have a date night.
None of those situations fit neatly into the sleep training schedule I had imagined.
The advice I kept hearing was, "Whatever you do, just be consistent." While I understand why consistency matters, I also realized that life with a baby isn't always consistent.
One evening, Grandma put our son to sleep with a bottle instead of following our sleep training routine.
A few months earlier, I probably would have panicked. I would have worried that we had ruined all of our progress.
Instead, we simply started again the next night.
And you know what?
He was fine.
That was such an important lesson for me.
Sleep training isn't about executing every bedtime perfectly. It's about helping your child gradually learn a new skill over time.
When I stopped treating every setback like a failure, the entire process became less stressful.
I also stopped putting so much pressure on my husband and myself. We weren't trying to be perfect parents anymore—we were simply trying to be loving, consistent parents who were doing our best.
I like to think of it the same way we teach our children to ride a bike.
They don't master it in one afternoon.
They wobble.
They fall.
They need encouragement.
Sometimes they take a step backward before moving forward again.
Learning to fall asleep independently isn't all that different.
Your child doesn't need you to be perfect.
They just need you to lovingly guide them through a new skill, one bedtime at a time.
If I could give one piece of advice to parents thinking about sleep training, it would be this:
Talk to your partner before you start.
Trust me—you do not want to be having your first big conversation about sleep training while your baby is scream crying in the other room.
Before you begin, sit down together and talk it through.
Why do you want to sleep train?
What are you both worried about?
What method feels right for your family?
Are there any boundaries you want to set? For example, is there a point where you'll stop trying for the night and try again tomorrow?
The more you talk beforehand, the less you'll have to figure out in the middle of an emotional moment.
My husband and I learned this the hard way.
The first time we tried sleep training, every time our son cried, I found myself looking to my husband for reassurance.
When he questioned whether we were doing the right thing, even if he was simply voicing his own fears, I immediately started doubting myself too.
Instead of feeling like we were a team, it sometimes felt like one of us was being the "good parent" while the other was being the "bad parent."
That was incredibly difficult.
The second time around, we did things differently.
Before we started, we talked through our concerns. We agreed on our plan, discussed what we were comfortable with, and made sure we both understood why we had chosen that approach.
That didn't make listening to our son cry any easier.
But it did make it easier to support each other.
There were nights when my husband took over bedtime so I could go for a walk or simply have a few quiet minutes to myself. Because we had already agreed on our plan, I didn't spend those moments wondering whether he was doing something different. I trusted him completely.
Looking back, I think that's one of the greatest gifts you can give each other during sleep training.
Not perfection.
Not all the answers.
Just the confidence of knowing you're facing a difficult season together.
Sleep training can be hard on babies.
But if we're honest, it can be just as emotionally exhausting for parents.
Having your partner beside you makes all the difference.
If you're anything like me, once you've made up your mind to do something, you just want to get it over with.
That's exactly what happened the first time we tried sleep training.
The idea had been bouncing around in my head for weeks. One night, while putting my son to bed, I thought, "Maybe tonight is the night."
There wasn't really a plan.
I hadn't thought through how the next few days would look.
My husband and I hadn't fully talked everything through.
I simply decided to give it a try.
Looking back, I'm not surprised we gave up.
When your baby has been crying for twenty or thirty minutes and you're already questioning yourself, it's incredibly easy to quit if you haven't prepared yourself mentally beforehand.
The second time we approached sleep training very differently.
We chose a start date that worked well for our family.
I even took my son out of daycare for a week because I wanted to keep our routine as calm and predictable as possible. I wanted plenty of time to make nutritious meals, stick to a regular nap schedule, and avoid rushing from one activity to the next.
We also tried not to schedule any major family events or outings that week.
Did everything still go according to plan?
Of course not.
Babies are wonderfully unpredictable.
But having a plan gave us confidence when things became difficult.
Instead of making emotional decisions in the middle of bedtime, we could remind ourselves why we had chosen to start that particular week.
If I could go back and give myself one piece of advice, it would be this:
Don't start sleep training because you're frustrated after one difficult bedtime.
Start when you've had time to do your research, talk with your partner, and prepare yourself emotionally for the process.
You don't need the perfect week.
You just need to feel ready.
Because once you've made that decision, it becomes much easier to stay calm and follow through when bedtime gets hard.
If there was one emotion that made sleep training harder than anything else, it was guilt.
Every cry made me wonder if I was making the wrong decision.
Every difficult bedtime made me question whether I should just give him one more bottle.
I wanted to protect my son from every hard feeling.
But then I realized something.
As parents, we ask our children to do hard things all the time.
We buckle them into car seats, even when they cry.
We take away candy before dinner.
We hold their hand while they get their vaccinations.
Not because we enjoy seeing them upset, but because we know it's what's best for them in the long run.
For our family, helping our son learn to fall asleep without a bottle felt like one of those moments.
That didn't make it easy.
But it did help me separate my guilt from what I believed was the right decision for our family.
During the first week of sleep training, my son definitely wanted more cuddles.
So I gave them to him.
I slowed down.
I didn't fill our days with errands or activities.
I made sure he knew that even though bedtime looked different, my love for him hadn't changed.
Before long, he became more confident.
Bedtime became less stressful.
Sleep training slowly faded into the background, and we moved on to new adventures together.
Looking back now, I realize that parenting is full of moments like this.
Our children won't always like the boundaries we set.
They won't always understand the decisions we make.
But boundaries are one of the ways we show love.
Children thrive when they know they're safe, cared for, and guided by parents who are willing to make difficult decisions—even when those decisions are emotionally hard.
If you're in the middle of sleep training right now, I know how overwhelming it can feel.
I know how guilty you may feel every time your little one cries.
I know you're probably wondering if you're doing the right thing.
Only you can decide what's best for your child and your family.
But if you've made that decision thoughtfully and lovingly, try not to let guilt convince you that you're a bad parent.
One day, this season will be behind you.
One day, your child will fall asleep on their own.
And one day, you'll look back and realize that one of the hardest parts of parenting wasn't the crying.
It was learning to trust yourself.
You've got this.
One of the biggest surprises of becoming a parent is realizing that there isn't a perfect roadmap. Every child is different. Every family is different. And no matter how many books you read or experts you listen to, there will always come a point where you have to trust your instincts and make the best decision you can with the information you have.
That's what this experience taught me.
Sleep training wasn't just about helping my son learn to sleep independently.
It was about helping me grow into a more confident mother.
Maybe that's the lesson I'll carry with me long after this season is over.
Join the letter and I’ll send the Morning Routine Printables to your inbox.
No spam, ever. Unsubscribe anytime.